Even if you're not hunting real game, nothing tops off a day of firing rounds like eating lots of red meat. >>
October 25, 2008
Issue: Oct 17 2008
In This Issue
October 25, 2008
In This Issue: Ripasso & Amarone & Party Wines
Steve Thurlow Returns
I am pleased to announce the return of long-time Wine Access Contributing Editor, Steve Thurlow, to the FIL reviewing team. Steve has contributed to FIL in the past and continues to work closely with Wine Access as part of the national tasting panel. Steve will be reviewing wines from time to time for FIL, that is, when he is not off conducting tours to some of the most beautiful wine regions in the world or teaching courses on wines. For anyone interested in expanding their wine knowledge, Steve offers Global Wine Tour wine courses, exploring the world of wine one country at a time. A list of upcoming courses in downtown Toronto is available in the Upcoming events section of the report.
Ripasso & Amarone
This week's LCBO-Vintages release highlights the red wines from the Valpolicella DOC situated in the Veneto in the northeast corner of Italy. The vineyards here, covering the foothills to the north of the charming town of Verona where Italy's largest wine fair, Vinitaly, is held every year, produce a wide range of red wines from light, simple and quaffable, to serious, full-bodied and age-worthy. All of these wines are blends, of which the 3 main grape varieties are: Corvina, Rondinela and Molinara. Corvina makes up the majority of quality wines, Rondinella usually in lesser proportions, and Molinara, considered the least interesting of the three is slowly being phased out. Other grapes are permitted in small percentages, including international grapes like Cabernet and Merlot as well as other Italian but non-local varieties like Sangiovese. So with all of these possibilities you can imagine how far ranging the wines styles are. But then add to that the unique and varied wine production methods employed in Valpolicella, and the scene becomes even more fascinating.
The powerful maritime Republic of Venice (capital of the Veneto region) dominated trade in the Mediterranean and Aegean seas for centuries during the middle ages and early Renaissance. In addition to being a staging ground for the Crusades, the city became a flourishing trade center between Western Europe and the Byzantine Empire. At the height of its power in the late thirteenth century, Venice was the richest city in all of Europe, and "Venice's leading families vied with each other to build the grandest palaces and support the work of the greatest and most talented artists". Merchants of all kinds brought back untold riches to Venice, and many of these treasures are still on display in the city. In fact, the doges of Venice levied a tax on all merchants using the port of Venice, requiring each returning ship to offer a token of appreciation to the city's rulers, in addition to monetary taxes. The main items of trade were silk, grains and spices, though wine, brought mostly from Greece, was also an important commodity.
This last tidbit is the one of greatest interest to us here, because Venetian merchants brought back not only wine to Italy, but also the Greek "technology" for making it. When the Ottoman Empire (and its religious disdain for alcoholic beverages) expanded into Greece, the main source of wine for trade more or less vanished. By then, however, citizens of the Italian peninsula had developed a taste for the full-bodied, mostly sweet wines of Greece made from partially sun-dried grapes. This is one of the oldest ways of making wines stable enough to survive long sea voyages.
Left without a supply of wines for the demanding market, Venetian merchants turned to the vineyards inland from their wealthy city to produce the wines that the market desired. The technique of drying grapes to concentrate wine is called appassimento in Italian, and the resulting wine, vino passito. One of the more famous Greek versions of this style of wine, widely exported to Venice and Western Europe during times of trade, was the wine from the Island of Santorini. This Vino di Santorini proved very popular and became known simply as vissanto or vinsanto. The Italian version of Vinsanto, produced from partially raisined grapes throughout the country but most famously in Tuscany, owes it origins and name to the wine of Santorini, and not, as many Italians will insist, to its use for holy (santo) occasions. At least that is one of the more likely stories.
Passito style wines are still widely produced in Italy today, but perhaps, aside from Vinsanto, nowhere more famously than in the Veneto and particularly in the "valley of many cellars" the Valpolicella denomination. (The classico denomination refers to wines produced in the original heartland of the area centered on the foothills, whereas non-classico wines can be produced anywhere in the large DOC including less interesting flatlands by the Po river; superiore refers to wines with an extra measure of ripeness at harvest and thus slightly higher alcohol.)
Here, from the same vineyards and same grape varieties, producers can make a huge range of wines. The harvest begins with the collection of regularly ripened grapes, from which straight up, fresh and fruity Valpolicella is produced. A portion of the harvested grapes are then set out to dry partially, losing about 30-40% of their water content over a period of several months. Traditionally the drying was done in barns up in the cool, breezy hills, though today temperature and humidity-controlled, purpose-built drying rooms are increasingly employed.
The concentrated grapes are then vinified into full bodied red wine. Depending on how concentrated the grapes are, the resulting wine may be anywhere from dry to sweet. These latter dessert-style wines are referred to as Reciotto della Valpolicella (Classico, Superiore), the name being derived from the prized part of the grape bunch traditionally used to make them, the recie, or ears of the bunch (the lobes on either side). If the grapes are not as concentrated, or if the yeast run wild and accidentally convert all of the sugar into alcohol, you end up with a dry, full-bodied, high alcohol, powerful wine with a raisined but slightly bitter taste. These wines, formerly known as Reciotto della Valpolicella Amarone, ("the big, bitter (dry) reciotto of Valpolicella" from the Italian word for bitter, amaro), are now simply known as Amarone della Valpolicella.
The thrifty and frugal Venetians, realizing after separating and pressing the skins during Amarone production that there was yet still a little more money to be squeezed out, took to reusing the pomace to give their simple fruity Valpolicella a little flavour boost. They "passed back" the pomace into the basic wine, thereby inducing another minor fermentation, using up the remaining sugars and adding additional flavour, body and alcohol in the process. Valpolicella "Ripasso" was born. Clever indeed. Until recently, however, there were no regulations concerning the production of ripasso (one producer, Masi, even managed to trademark the term until it was forced to relinquish its use to all the producers of Valpolicella). Today, the only regulation in place is that you can only produce twice as much ripasso as amarone in a given vintage. Thus if you declare 100 liters of Amarone, you can legally produce up to 200 liters of ripasso. So, some are made in the traditional way while others can be made from very lightly raisined fruit or even by adding some Amarone directly into your Valpolicella. There is no way of telling from the label, so go by what you like.
So that's my brief history of the fascinating wines of Valpolicella and the clever producers who make them. Just imagine, from the same plot of land, same vintage and same grapes, no fewer than 4 wine styles can be made: light and fruity Valpolicella, slightly more full-bodied Valpolicella Ripasso, full-bodied, rich but dry Amarone, and sweet, dessert style Reciotto! But of course the Venetians aren't finished there. Recognizing that there was still more money to be squeezed out of those grapes, they took to adding water and some sugar to the leftovers of the leftovers, fermenting the mixture and then distilling it into a fiery clear spirit called grappa. Throw it into a hand-blown glass bottle from the nearby Island of Murano and charge $100+ a bottle for it, and you are feeling pretty clever indeed!
You'll find a range of Valpolicella wines to choose from in this release, from the near sublime to sub-standard. I expect a good Amarone to have a rich, full body with plenty of raisined fruit extract and not too much volatile acidity, the smell of nail polish remover or acetone that can often accompany passito wines if not controlled properly. The use of wood varies widely, but as usual I am looking for a balance of fruit, wood and spice rather than a dominance of any one element. Ripasso in my opinion should have some of that raisined character, yet still be pleasantly drinkable without excessive tannins. My top 6, those scoring 89 or above, are listed for your reference.
The other theme of the release, party wines, is pretty straightforward and self-explanatory. Usually a host is looking for wines with mass appeal, that is, safe, pleasantly fruity wines in which nothing sticks out, at a reasonable price. Very distinctive wines can be more risky to serve, as the stronger the personality, the more clearly the dividing line between like and dislike is drawn. Unless of course you have a room full of die-hard aficionados on the look-out for something different and unique. The top ten smart buys lays out the value part of the equation, but for stylistic considerations, refer to the tasting notes.
Coming Up:
November 8th Vintages release focusing on Bordeaux and Premium Spirits.
Events:
The usual listing of wine events happening in Ontario is included at the end of the report.
Blog Spot: check for new postings at: www.wineaccess.ca/blog/jszabo.
Cheers,
John Szabo, MS.
Top 10 Smart Buys
| 10 |
Casa Silva 2006 Reserva Carmenère **_ Colchagua Valley, Chile |
ON $15 | ![]() |
||
| 9 |
KWV 2005 Cathedral Cellar Chardonnay*** Western Cape, South Africa |
ON $15 | ![]() |
||
| 8 |
Lurton 2006 Reserva Malbec *** Mendoza, Argentina |
ON $14 | ![]() |
||
| 7 |
Salustri 2005 Santa Marta Single Vineyard Montecucco Sangiovese *** Tuscany, Italy |
ON $41 | ![]() |
||
| 6 |
Nino Negri 2004 Sasselle 'Le Tense' Valtellina Superiore *** Lombardia, Italy |
ON $25 | ![]() |
||
| 5 |
Haras de Pirque 2004 Character Cabernet Sauvignon*** Maipo Valley, Chile |
ON $20 | ![]() |
||
| 4 |
Cathedral Cellar 2006 Triptych*** Coastal Region, South Africa |
ON $17 | ![]() |
||
| 3 |
Wynns 2005 Coonawarra Estate Cabernet Sauvignon**_ Coonawarra, Australia |
ON $25 | ![]() |
||
| 2 |
Ruffino 2004 Serelle Vin Santo Del Chianti *** Tuscany, Itay |
ON $20 | ![]() |
||
| 1 |
Gonzalez Byass N/V Del Duque Amontillado *** Spain |
ON $34 | ![]() |
|
|
||||||||
|
|||||||||
| back to top | |||||||||
| Argentina - Red | |||||||||
|
|
||||||||
|
|
||||||||
| back to top | |||||||||
| Australia - Red | |||||||||
|
|
||||||||
|
|
||||||||
|
|||||||||
| back to top | |||||||||
| Australia - White | |||||||||
|
|||||||||
| back to top | |||||||||
| Canada - Red | |||||||||
|
|||||||||
| back to top | |||||||||
| Canada - White | |||||||||
|
|||||||||
| back to top | |||||||||
| Chile - Red | |||||||||
|
|
||||||||
|
|
||||||||
| back to top | |||||||||
| France - Red | |||||||||
|
|
||||||||
|
|
||||||||
|
|
||||||||
|
|
||||||||
| back to top | |||||||||
| France - Sparkling | |||||||||
|
|||||||||
| back to top | |||||||||
| France - White | |||||||||
|
|
||||||||
|
|
||||||||
|
|
||||||||
| back to top | |||||||||
| Germany - White | |||||||||
|
|
||||||||
| back to top | |||||||||
| Hungary - White | |||||||||
|
|||||||||
| back to top | |||||||||
| Italy - Fortified/Dessert | |||||||||
|
|||||||||
| back to top | |||||||||
| Italy - Red | |||||||||
|
|
||||||||
|
|
||||||||
|
|
||||||||
|
|
||||||||
|
|
||||||||
|
|
||||||||
|
|
||||||||
|
|
||||||||
|
|
||||||||
|
|
||||||||
|
|
||||||||
|
|||||||||
| back to top | |||||||||
| Italy - White | |||||||||
|
|
||||||||
| back to top | |||||||||
| New Zealand - Red | |||||||||
|
|
||||||||
|
|||||||||
| back to top | |||||||||
| New Zealand - White | |||||||||
|
|
||||||||
| back to top | |||||||||
| Portugal - Red | |||||||||
|
|||||||||
| back to top | |||||||||
| South Africa - Red | |||||||||
|
|
||||||||
| back to top | |||||||||
| South Africa - White | |||||||||
|
|||||||||
| back to top | |||||||||
| Spain - Fortified/Dessert | |||||||||
|
|
||||||||
| back to top | |||||||||
| Spain - Red | |||||||||
|
|||||||||
| back to top | |||||||||
| United States - Red | |||||||||
|
|
||||||||
|
|
||||||||
| back to top | |||||||||
| United States - Sparkling | |||||||||
|
|||||||||
| back to top | |||||||||
| United States - White | |||||||||
|
|
||||||||
|
|||||||||
| back to top | |||||||||
Features
Ripasso & Amarone
1. 356220 TOMMASI 2004 AMARONE DELLA VALPOLICELLA CLASSICO 91 $53 **½
2. 13417 BERTANI 2004 AMARONE DELLA VALPOLICELLA VALPANTENA 91 $57 **½
3. 85159 STEFANO ACCORDINI 2005 VALPOLICELLA CLASSICO SUPERIORE ACINATICO RIPASSO 90 $29 **½
4. 84061 CORTE MAJOLI 2003 VALPOLICELLA SUPERIORE 89 $20 **½
5. 85340 GAMBA GNIREGA 2004 AMARONE DELLA VALPOLICELLA CLASSICO LE QUARE 89 $51 **
6. 413179 ZENATO 2004 AMARONE DELLA VALPOLICELLA CLASSICO 89 $53 **
Upcoming Global Wine Tour course conducted by Steve Thurlow:
October 24/08 Exploring The Wines Of South Africa
November 5/08 Exploring The Wines Of Spain
December 11/08 Exploring The Wines Of New Zealand
See Globalwinetour.com for details and registration, and visit www.stevethurlow.com to find out more about what Steve is up to these days.
Upcoming Events
October
- 20
"Me and My Jadot" - The Ultimate Fine Wine Dinner (6:30 p.m., Champagne Reception followed by a Burgundian feast prepared by the Master chefs at the Four Seasons Hotel; Presented by Lifford Wine Agency in association with Grapes for Humanity -- Donations of wine readily accepted for the silent auction) -- Tony Aspler, tony.aspler@sympatico.ca
- 23
Regional Heroes Master Class Trade Seminar (11:30 a.m.-2:30 p.m.; Juniper Kitchen and Wine Bar, 245 Richmond Road, Ottawa) -- Marnie Williamson, Wine Australia, 416/323-1893, marnie.williamson@austrade.gov.au, www.wineaustralia.com
- 23
Vintages Château Haut-Brion Structured Tasting & Dinner (6:15 p.m., Structured Tasting; 7:15 p.m., Champagne Reception; 8 p.m., Dinner; Splendido Restaurant, 88 Harbord Street, Toronto; Featuring Estate Manager Jean-Philippe Delmas, son of legendary oenologist Jean Bernard Delmas) -- LCBO Vintages Sales and Service Centre, 416/365-5767, 1-800/266-4764 (Sold Out)
- 24
Whisky Live (4-10 p.m.; Hall G, Metro Toronto Convention Centre, 255 Front Street West, Toronto) -- Damian Riley-Smith, Paragraph Publishing Ltd., + 44 1603 633 808, www.whiskylive.com
- 24-26
Vintages Wine Auction (Ritchies Auction House, 288 King Street East, Toronto) -- John Miller, Ritchies, 416/364-3902, jmiller@ritchies.com
- 29
Vintages Wine 101 (6 p.m., Reception; 6:30-9 p.m., Tasting; Fairmont Chateau Laurier, 1 Rideau Street, Ottawa) -- LCBO Vintages Sales and Service Centre, 416/365-5767, 1-800/266-4764
November
- 3
ICE Annual Wine Tasting (11 a.m. - 5 p.m., Trade Tasting; 7-10 p.m., Consumer Tasting; Roy Thomson Hall, 60 Simcoe Street, Toronto; Supporting the Heart & Stroke Foundation of Ontario) -- Benedetta Marassi, Italian Trade Commission, 416/598-1566, benedetta.marassi.toronto@ice.it
- 6
Wines of Argentina Tasting (3-6:30 p.m., Trade Tasting; 7-11 p.m., Consumer Tasting; The Design Exchange, 235 Bay Street, Toronto) -- Ariel Menniti, amenniti@winesofargentina.org, www.winesofargentina.com.ar
- 7-9
23rd Annual Ottawa Wine and Food Show (November 7 and 8, 12-9 p.m.; November 9, 11:30 a.m.-5:30 p.m.; Lansdowne Park, 1015 Bank Street, Ottawa) -- Joan Culliton, 613/523-9463, joan@ottawawineandfoodshow.com
- 21
2008 Beaujolais Festival (6 p.m.; The Dominion Club, 1 King Street West, Toronto -- This festival celebrates the arrival of Beaujolais Nouveau as well as the 10 Beaujolais Crus that are the jewels in Beaujolais' crown -- Brouilly, Chénas, Chiroubles, Côte-de-Brouilly, Fleurie, Juliénas, Morgon, Moulin à Vent, Régnié, and Saint Amour) -- French Chamber of Commerce in Canada (Toronto Chapter), 416/205-9820, ccfe@bellnet.ca
- 24
French Wine Connection (Toronto; 11 a.m.- 5 p.m.; Trade Tasting; The Fermenting Cellar, Distillery Historic District, 55 Mill Street, Toronto; Featuring French wines not yet available in the Ontario market) -- Aude Guivarch, French Trade Commission, 416/977-1257, Ext. 220, aude.guivarch@missioneco.org
- 27
OIWSBA Members' Meeting (8:30 Breakfast, 9 a.m. Meeting; Ballroom, Boulevard Club, 1491 Lakeshore Boulevard West, Toronto; Final Business Meeting of 2008; The LCBO's Dr. George Soleas will discuss Consignment and Quality Assurance issues) -- Ian Campbell, OIWSBA, 416/699-9535, ian.campbell@oiwsba.com, www.oiwsba.com
December
- 6-7
Vintages Wine Auction (Ritchies Auction House, 288 King Street East, Toronto) -- John Miller, Ritchies, 416/364-3902, jmiller@ritchies.com
Additional Reviews
Australia - Red
90 Dog Ridge 2006 The Pup Cabernet Merlot ***
McLaren Vale
Really inviting, ripe but not jammy black fruit and distinctive spice, herbal, tobacco, black licorice - above average complexity without excessive oak. Dry, fullish, soft, plush tannins, balanced acidity, and moderate (for McLaren Vale) alcohol of 14%. This shows a lot of style and class for the money in a food-friendly Cabernet-Merlot, designed for short the mid-term cellaring. (JS)
ON: $20.95
Agent: Le Sommelier
89 Dog Ridge 2006 The Pup Shiraz **1/2
McLaren Vale
Sweet cacao, coffee and dark chocolate mingles with black cherry liqueur, roasted plum and a lifted hint of eucalyptus. Dry, fullish, fat and succulent sweet fruit, adequate acidity and soft plush tannins lend this a highly appealing texture. Moderate finish. A well-made, clearly new world style Shiraz that is ready to drink now or will hold 2-4 years or more. (JS)
ON: $20.95
Agent: Le Sommelier
91 Dog Ridge 2006 Square Cut Cabernet **1/2
McLaren Vale
Still reticent on the nose, showing just a glimpse of earth, tobacco spice, cassis, and ripe but not jammy black fruit. The wine then opens with aeration to reveal additional layers of depth and complexity. The palate is dry, firm, savoury, herbal, dark spice, with intense flavours, moderate tannins, balanced acidity and enough class and elegance to make this more interesting than the average. (JS)
ON: $35.95
Agent: Le Sommelier
90 Ardent Estates 2004 Cabernet Franc **1/2
Adelaide Hills
Very intense, fragrant, spicy and floral black fruit, eucalyptus, black cherry essence and black raspberry aromas. Dry, fullish, ripe, rich succulent black fruit character on the palate, soft silky tannins. A bit of heat sticks out on the finish, but lingering flavours of tobacco, coffee, black fruit and faded violets add degrees of interest and class. (JS)
ON: $22.95
Agent: Le Sommelier
87 Ardent Estates 2005 Shiraz **
McLaren Vale
Clean, savoury, earthy, black cherry essence, wet bark, tobacco, above average complexity. Dry, full, soft tannins, moderate intensity and complexity, average length finish. Lots on the nose but the palate seems to fall short here. Drink now. (JS)
ON: $23.95
Agent: Le Sommelier
88 Ardent Estates 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon **
McLaren Vale
A full rich, mouth filling, sweet black fruit-flavoured red with dusty tannins and generous alcohol that offers a lot on the nose and up front on the palate, but finishes precipitously. This should be enjoyed in the near term with hearty fare. (JS)
ON: $23.95
Agent: Le Sommelier
Australia - White
87 Dog Ridge 2008 The Pup Sauvignon Blanc **
McLaren Vale
Clean, fresh, green tropical fruit notes, pineapple, honeydew melon, key lime pie - ripe but not overtly herbaceous. Dry, medium body, juicy acidity, pleasant youthful banana, lime, grapefruit and candied green apple flavours, bright acidity and moderate finish. A pleasant, refreshing wine designed for pleasure in the short term. (JS)
ON: $20.95
Agent: Le Sommelier
88 Ardent Estates 2008 Unwooded Chardonnay **1/2
Adelaide Hills
This is a ripe & zesty unoaked chardonnay from the relatively cool zone of the Adelaide Hills. Youthful, straight out of the fermentation vat aromas of green apple, pineapple, melon and green peach dominate the nose. The palate shows above average concentration and an almost sweet impression, given the ripeness and intensity of fruit. Moderate length. this will provide enjoyment over the next 2-3 years. (JS)
ON: $20.95
Agent: Le Sommelier
Canada - Red
87 Le Clos Jordanne 2006 Village Reserve Pinot Noir **
Twenty Mile Bench
Light, delicately perfumed, high-toned aromas with distinct herbal-vegetal notes and a hint of volatile acidity and faded violet/rose petals. Dry, light-bodied, high acid, low-medium tannins; just a hint of wood and rusticity emerge on the finish. Clearly a Pinot from a lighter vintage compared to previous editions of the village reserve, destined for enjoyment in the short term. (JS)
ON: $30.00
Agent: Vincor
89 Le Clos Jordanne 2006 La Petite Vineyard Pinot Noir **1/2
Twenty Mile Bench
Very fine and delicate here again, with high-toned perfume and faded rose petals alongside tart red berry/cherry, cranberry, with just a hint of dried berry fruit and sweet wet earth. The palate is lively and juicy, with lovely silky tannins and succulent acidity, lingering nicely on perfumed-floral and limestone mineral notes. Certainly more Volnay in style, to use a Burgundian comparison. (JS)
ON: $40.00
Agent: Vincor
89 Le Clos Jordanne 2006 Claystone Terrace Pinot Noir **1/2
Twenty Mile Bench
The deepest in colour of the range, as usual. Somewhat closed at the moment, though shows a distinct rusty iron-like minerality, spice and earth. Dry, fullish, solidly built with pronounced (for Pinot) tannins and juicy acidity. The finish is pinched somewhat. Claystone is the chewiest and meatiest of the lot, the most new world out of a clearly old world range. (JS)
ON: $40.00
Agent: Vincor
91 Le Clos Jordanne 2006 Le Clos Jordanne Vineyard Pinot Noir **1/2
Twenty Mile Bench
Closed at the moment on the nose, just barely showing some sweet dried floral notes, elegant and delicate. Fullish, round, soft and silky yet with enough substance and grip to hold and improve in the short to midterm. This has an extra measure depth and length on the palate as well as an immediately appealing satiny texture. Fruit trends to succulent raspberry and strawberry. A real "hedonist's wine, the most gourmand" according to winemaker Thomas Bachelder. (JS)
ON: $65.00
Agent: Vincor
91 Le Clos Jordanne 2006 Le Grand Clos Pinot Noir **1/2
Twenty Mile Bench
Sweet, fresh red raspberry, fully integrated light wood notes and cinnamon spice - still a bit closed. Dry, medium-bodied; wood notes are more prevalent on the palate, lending a sweet caramel finish and rounding out the tannins to a silky sheen. This is remarkably ready to drink but I suspect it will continue to improve over the next 2-4 years and hold an additional couple beyond that. A lighter, more delicate and transparent version of the Grand Clos, representative of the vintage. (JS)
ON: $70.00
Agent: Vincor
Canada - White
88 Le Clos Jordanne 2006 Village Reserve Chardonnay **
Twenty Mile Bench
Subdued, resinous notes off the top, followed by mineral and fresh stone fruit, pear and apple aromas. Dry, firm textured, pronounced acidity and really finely integrated wood that makes a subtle backdrop. Stylish and flavourful, very old world and infinitely food-friendly. (JS)
ON: $30.00
Agent: Vincor
91 Le Clos Jordanne 2006 Claystone Terrace Chardonnay **1/2
Twenty Mile Bench
A little more color and ripeness apparently on the nose, including some white mushroom and slightly smoky, flinty notes and grapefruit, honeydew and Anjou pear. Dry, fullish, solid and succulent on the palate with palpable grip and high flavour intensity. Again, Claystone's solid, almost rustic side shows through, offering a full flavoured yet intriguingly mineral expression for mid-term cellaring. (JS)
ON: $40.00
Agent: Vincor
92 Le Clos Jordanne 2006 Le Clos Jordanne Vineyard Chardonnay *** T
wenty Mile Bench
Wonderful purity of expression on the nose, showing distinctly floral-mineral notes - this seems to have it all. Fullish, soft, silky, succulent and refined texture, stone fruit and ripe lemon/meyer lemon flavours, and long, lingering finish. Lots of class and distinction here - seems to have the most finesse, and great affinity for food. (JS)
ON: $40.00
Agent: Vincor
90 Le Clos Jordanne 2006 Le Grand Clos Chardonnay **
Twenty Mile Bench
The Grand clos is a bit awkward on the nose, showing earth, wood mushroom and light vegetal notes; the fruit is not currently there. On the palate its dry, palpably grippy on the palate; generous alcohol lends a warm finish. Solid and structured, just not together yet, so consider the score provisional. (JS)
ON: $70.00
Agent: Vincor
Chile - Red
87 Errazuriz 2007 Carmenère Estate ***
Aconcagua Valley
Clean, moderate intensity, ripe but not overripe red and black fruit, spicy pepper, hints of violet and chocolate, cold cream. Dry, medium body and concentration, well balanced, pleasant fruity and light wood chocolate flavours, low, soft plush tannins, average length. Pleasant, pliable and versatile version of Carmenère. Great party wine. (JS)
ON: $13.80
Agent: Philippe Dandurand
89 Errazuriz 2006 Max Reserva Cabernet Sauvignon ***
Aconcagua Valley
A slightly cooler year; this shows considerable freshness and marked herbal notes, black licorice, cassis - almost old world in style. Dry, fullish, lively, juicy acid, moderate, ripe tannins, fine flavour intensity. Quite delicate and spicy, integrated chocolaty oak. Above average finish. A very fine value in sub-$20 premium wine. (JS)
ON: $18.00
Agent: Philippe Dandurand
93 Montes 2005 Montes Alpha "M" **
Colchagua valley
The 2005 "M" Bordeaux blend dominated by Cabernet Sauvignon has a ripe, elegant nose with lots of class and finesse. Fruit character is quite plush but not jammy, with plenty of high-quality new wood and high complexity. The palate is full and round, with abundant velvety tannins that are well coated in fruit extract and generous alcohol. Long, warm finish. This should be at its best from 2010-2020. (JS)
ON: $82.00
Agent: Whitehall Agencies
92 Montes 2005 Montes Folly **
Colchagua Valley
Montes' Iconic 100% Syrah has highly characteristic ultra ripe black fruit aromas overlying, sweet cacao and caramel wood notes in an unabashedly new world style. The palate shows remarkable finesse and suave, delicate but abundant tannins that lends structure and framework to support the luxuriant fruit and oak. Although highly accessible now, this should continue to improve over the next decade or so and hold even longer. (JS)
ON: $82.00
Agent: Whitehall Agencies
93 Montes 2005 Montes Purple Angel ***
Colchagua Valley
Montes make no effort here to hide the characteristic herbal-vegetal notes that is part of the Carmenère genetic make-up, seemingly enhancing even some of the brighter top notes and showcasing the floral-violet side of the grape as well. The palate though reveals fully ripe fruit and sweet tannins, which are present in abundance, adding a touch of grip. High alcohol underscores the ripeness, and seductive wood and herbal notes carry through to the long finish. A very fine and refined example of the variety (though perhaps less so than the more mainstream Cabernet and Syrah), destined to be enjoyed now-2018 or more. Super value here. (JS)
ON: $51.00
Agent: Whitehall Agencies
89 Lapostolle 2006 Cuvée Alexandre Cabernet Sauvignon
Apalta Vineyard, Colchagua Valley
Curious resinous, herbal and underlying vegetal notes that speak to the difficulty of the vintage - the wine seems at an awkward stage of development currently. The palate is quite fresh and juicy, however, showing fine vibrancy, lively acidity and moderate, smartly extracted tannins. Above average finish. This should offer a lot (JS)
ON: $34.95
Agent: Diageo
95 Lapostolle 2005 Clos Apalta
Colchagua Valley
Carmenère 42%, with 26% Merlot and 28% Cabernet Sauvignon, 4% Petit Verdot (planted in 2000), all hand-destemmed. Exuberant, ultra ripe black fruit and spice on the nose; new wood is almost fully absorbed by the concentration - great complexity, The palate is full and surprisingly solid, with abundant, chewy, but ripe and plush tannins. This is a real mouthful of wine and a seeming departure from previous vintages that were less structured and probably less age worthy. The 2005 Apalta will be a wine for the ages, already showing its class and depth. Best 2012-2025. (JS)
Agent: Diageo
91 Errazuriz 2005 La Cumbre
Aconcagua Valley
Very intense dark chocolate notes dominate the nose, plenty of sweet new wood evident, vanilla, black fruit, ripe fig, verging on jam. Dry, full, bit with surprising acidity - a little more structured and firm than expected from the generous nose. This should age quite well to 2020. (JS)
91 Errazuriz 2005 Kai
Aconcagua Valley
Ripe, roasted vegetal notes - fine Carmenère character, ripe black fruit and violets. Dry, soft, low acid expression, fine, soft and ripe tannins. Plush and ready for early pleasure. (JS)
92 Errazuriz 2005 Don Maximiniano
Aconcagua Valley
Moderate intensity - seems to be a little closed at the moment, but shows underlying class and elegance, integrated wood and spice, and sweet blue fruit character. Dry, full bodied, lots of finesse on the palate, with additional lifted floral notes and suave, silky texture. This is drinking well now, but should hold until 2018. (JS)
93 Seña 2005 Seña
Closed and a bit resinous, with marked wood influence, chocolate and coffee notes over ripe black fruit. Dry, fullish, balanced, juicy, elegant structure, very long finish. Plenty of class here and lingering flavour. This will be at its best from 2010-2020. (JS)
Chile - White
88 Errazuriz 2008 Sauvignon Blanc Estate ***
Casablanca Valley
Considered by Señor Chadwick to be a very strong vintage for white wines. From the north-east part of the valley, a slightly warmer zone. Very clean, fresh, fragrant, intensely fruity and perfumed, passion fruit, ripe citrus (harvested at two times, two weeks apart to capture a range of flavours and degrees of ripeness. Dry, bright, very fruity and juicy, lovely citrus notes with underlying tropical. moderate plus finish. Lovely sipping wine destined for immediate pleasure. Outrageous good value. (JS)
ON: $11.80
Agent: Philippe Dandurand
90 Lapostolle 2005 Cuvée Alexandre Atalayas Vineyard Chardonnay ***
Casablanca Valley
Delicate but ripe new world style Chardonnay, with attractive stone fruit character, pear, apple, and integrated high quality wood. The palate is fullish with some implicit sweetness and round, rich, pineapple and roasted pear carried on a very seductive, succulent frame. Long finish. Drink now-2012+ Lovely new world example. (JS)
ON: $28.00
Agent: Diageo
France - White
90 Domaines Pierre Gaillard 2007 Tremadoc Collioure Blanc ***
Roussillon
Really intriguing, classic old world style white, with apple, honey, lavender, wet stone, well above average complexity. Dry, fullish, round rich and creamy texture, high flavour, light barley sugar and caramelized apple finish. Long. A very fine, southern French white for a myriad of highly flavourful Mediterranean dishes. (JS)
ON: $26.00
Agent: The Case for Wine
91 Domaines Pierre Gaillard 2006 St. Joseph **
Rhône Valley
Advanced, rather mature aromas with custard and crème caramel, baked peach and apricot, dried flowers. Dry, fullish, very flavourful on the palate. Distinct fruit skin bitterness, moderate intensity and concentration and even a hint of mold/rot emerges. Give this a little air and it freshens up remarkably, revealing orange blossom honey and a full range of floral-stone fruit notes of fine class. (JS)
ON: $37.00
Agent: The Case for Wine
Italy - Red
87 Tenuta Caparzo 2007 IGT Toscana **1/2
Tuscany
Sangiovese is blended here with Syrah, Merlot and Cabernet Sauvignon to produce a modern, fresh, clean highly fruit driven, orange peel-scented red, with attractive cran-cherry notes. Dry, medium-bodied, moderate, juicy acid, moderate intensity and finish, ending on pleasant morello cherry notes. This is a hand bottled sample, the properly prepared bottle should have even brighter fruit. (JS)
ON: $17.00
Agent: The Case for Wine
88 Fattoria Ormanni 2005 Chianti Classico **
Tuscany
Clean but more traditional, earthy, cranberry, cherry style Chianti here with pleasant wet earth, tobacco, dark spice notes. Dry, medium-bodied, moderate but firm tannins, crisp acidity and moderate finish. For fans of old style Chianti, without the funk. (JS)
ON: $24.00
Agent: The Case for Wine
87 Az. Agr. Marco Porello 2007 Mommiano Barbera d'Alba **
Piedmont
Clean, fresh, juicy, just chalk full of dark cherry fruit - highly inviting. Dry, juicy, low tannins, crisp acid. Serve this chilled with anything from the salumiere. Fun, fresh, and delicious. (JS)
ON: $19.00
Agent: The Case for Wine
89 Poggio al Tesoro 2005 Sondraia IGT Toscana **
Bolgheri
The new Bolgheri project co-launched by Marilisa Allegrini of Veneto-Amarone fame and US importer Leonardo Locasio is a blend of Cabernet Sauvignon, Franc and Merlot. Clean, abundantly fruity, modern, average length. Correct. (JS)
ON: $55.00
Agent: Calibrium
92 Poggio al Tesoro 2005 "W" Dedicato a Walter **
Bolgheri
100% Cabernet Franc. Lifted nose of floral and light herbal components, surprisingly not overripe or overly modern. Ripe red and black fruit mingle with licorice. The palate is silky and delicate, with very fine grained tannins - just lightly grippy, moderate acidity and long intense finish with polished wood influence. (JS)
ON: $104.00
Agent: Calibrium
Italy - White
88 Az. Agr. Marco Porello 2007 Langhe Favorita **1/2
Piedmont
Light - moderate intensity, highly stony-mineral, citrus, lime, green peach-pear aromas. Dry, medium bodied, highly versatile and food friendly with its crisp citrusy acid and lingering juicy finish. Pleasant peach skin bitter notes and rather succulent, round texture. Delightful. (JS)
ON: $17.00
Agent: The Case for Wine
Mexico - Spirits
Casa Tradición NV Clase Azul Platino Tequila Plata
Jalisco
Kettle-steamed piña. Fresh, vegetal, pure agave flavours show some complexity and class. Distinctly sweet on the palate, round and suave texture, long, caramelized sugar finish. A very commercially appealing style. (JS)
ON: $90.00
Agent: Tre Amici
Casa Tradición NV Clase Azul Tequila Reposado
Jalisco
8 months in white oak. Intriguing, refined, sweet caramel-woody-baking spice nose like fine XO Cognac, mellow and complex. Round, soft, high intensity flavours and sweet caramel-crème brulée (JS)
ON: $140.00
Agent: Tre Amici
Spain - Red
87 El Bombero 2006 DO Cariñena ***
Aragón
Clean, strawberry jam-scented, simple but pleasant nose. Dry, medium bodied, soft, round pleasant, low tannins, average intensity and finish, but fruity and highly appealing. Great value in a by the glass selection. Can you believe that this is 15% alcohol? Wears it very well. (JS)
ON: $14.50
Agent: The Case for Wine
United States - Red
91 Silverado Vineyards 2004 Cabernet Sauvignon **1/2
Napa Valley
Clean, elegant, rather delicate aromas showing attractive floral, red and black fruit nuances, roasted plum, fresh herb and light spice - lovely. Dry, fine grained tannins, full but not overwhelming body. Long finish. This is a Napa Cabernet with plenty of style and elegance and no shortage of flavour. (JS)
ON: $50.00
Agent: Kylix
89 Silverado Vineyards 2005 Cabernet Sauvignon **
Napa Valley
A little darker and more herbal - wood spice, dried herbs, moderate intensity and complexity. Dry, light-medium-bodied, light but dusty, grippy tannins, a little hot on the finish. Moderate intensity. Correct. (JS)
ON: $50.00
Agent: Kylix
92 Silverado Vineyards 2005 Solo Cabernet Sauvignon Stag's Leap District **
Napa Valley
10,000 bottles produced. A heritage clone of Cabernet, called the Silverado clone. Rich, intense, coffee, abundant, high quality oak. Ripe black fruit, classic Napa nose. Dry, full, round, rich, soft plush tannins, long finish. A real classic, without the excessive oak and extract. Nice to see some finesse here. (JS)
ON: $90.00
Agent: Kylix
90 Justin Vineyards 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon **1/2
Paso Robles
Forward, open, fragrant, very ripe red fruit, strawberry, high-toned spice, thoroughly appealing and deliciously soft on the palate. Tannins are ripe and plush, and lower acidity gives an almost sweet impression on the palate. Moderate finish. Ready to drink now, should hold 2014+. (JS)
ON: $32.00
Agent: The Vine
90 Justin Vineyards 2006 Syrah **1/2
Paso Robles
100% Syrah. Deep, dark, spicy, mineral, violet, black fruit, integrated black pepper and wood spice - lots to contemplate on the nose. Dry, fullish, quite firm and driven by black cherry essence; high alcohol (15%) makes the palate quite warm and generous and gives it an almost jammy profile, but adequate acidity reigns in the fruit and gives focus. (JS)
ON: $34.00
Agent: The Vine
92 Justin Vineyards 2006 Savant **1/2
Paso Robles
A Provençal-inspired blend of 59% Syrah and 41% Cabernet, looking for structure from the Cab and colour and rich, sweet fruit from the Syrah. A part of Syrah is partially air dried before fermentation in open top fermenters. Rich, ripe, opulent aromas verging on dried black fruit, fig, date, cassis, in addition to more prominent new wood smoky influence. The palate is rich and full, with high alcohol, and moderate plus tannins that are so coated with fruit extract as to go almost unnoticed. Long finish. (JS)
ON: $52.00
Agent: The Vine
93 Justin Vineyards 2006 Justification ***
Paso Robles
The "right bank" blend to complement the "left bank" flagship Isosceles, with 2/3 Cabernet Franc and 1/3 merlot. Fragrant, high-toned, floral-violet, delicate red berry fruit, red cherry essence and a touch of mentholated herb. The palate is dry and delicate, with above average acidity and uncommon elegance from such a usually high-octane appellation. Tannins are fully ripe and unobtrusive, with a silky texture. Long finish. Really delightful food wine that should age well to the end of the next decade. (JS)
ON: $52.00
Agent: The Vine
92 Justin Vineyards 2005 Isoceles **
Paso Robles
Cabernet Sauvignon-dominated with Cabernet Franc and a pinch of Merlot. Big, deep, obviously concentrated nose, showing rich, superripe black fruit, dried herbs and scrub brush, dusty earth and black licorice. The palate is fully saturated with the flavour of cherries macerated in alcohol and well integrated wood notes; abundant but fully ripe tannins should enable this to last and improve over the next couple of decades. A little burly and unyielding for the moment. Drink from 2012-2025. (JS)
ON: $79.00
Agent: The Vine
United States - White
89 Silverado Vineyards 2007 Muller Ranch Sauvignon Blanc **1/2
Napa Valley
Clean, fresh, tropical expression of Sauvignon Blanc, lots of melon, papaya, mango and passion fruit, white peach and mandarin. Dry, medium bodied, creamy texture, essentially unoaked (there is a pinch of barrel fermented Semillon, but not strongly manifested). Nice fruity, expressive version; moderate finish. (JS)
ON: $24.00
Agent: Kylix
88 Silverado Vineyards 2006 Vineburg Chardonnay **
Carneros
Intriguing floral, honeysuckle, yeasty character, very moderate oak, apple, meyer lemon, slightly reductive though toasted nut/hazelnut. A perplexing wine, creamy texture but has some green apple like freshness. Strong lees character. (JS)
ON: Private Order - $35
Agent: Kylix
88 Justin Vineyards 2007 Chardonnay **
Paso Robles
8 months on wood, 1/4 new. Ripe, creamy, very well integrated oak, apple, pear, lemon-scented crème brulée - very attractive. Dry, with a streak of cleansing acidity and a two-sided personality with citrus green apple flavours matched by riper, creamier stone fruit notes - no malolactic fermentation here. Average finish. Correct, pleasant, well balanced style. (JS)
ON: $25.00
Agent: The Vine
IVWA RESULTS
All results online!
Full results of the Wine Access 2009 International Value Wine Awards appeared in the October/November 2009 issue of Wine Access and can be found online. Plus, extended Best by Country results available here only!
WINE BLOGS
The first part of what was an incredible trip this past January to Northern Italy as the guest of the Instituto Grandi Marchi. >>
WINE NEWS
Nashville will see a recreation of a historic Bordeaux tasting that demonstrates that price isn't everything in the wine world.
CWA RESULTS
Results are in!
Full results of the Wine Access 2009 Canadian Wine Awards appear in the December/January issue of Wine Access, on newsstands now and online.
Also online, an exclusive behind-the-scenes video of the 2009 CWA experience.





